This or That?

My friend Joey inspired me to go-a-shopping from some high quality look-a-like items for some high priced lovelies I've been lusting over.  Now the question is: this or that?

This: Kate Spade With a Twist Solid Rosette Top ($95)

buy here

That:  Rosette top @ Boden ($38)

buy here

This: Kate Spade Annapolis Agnes Sweater (on Sale for $172)

buy here

That: Boden Watermelon Strip Bow Cardi ($88)

buy here

This: Orange Vera Wang "Lillian" flat ($195)

buy here

That: Orange flat, Corso Como ($59.50)

buy here